About
About
About
About
About
About
About
About
About
About
About
Meaning of Home for Different Generations
Project Type
Team
Duration
Year
Ethnographic research project
Kesu Wang, HyunJin Kim, YongJoon Jhoo
14 weeks
2016
Project Goal
Reveal and compare the different beliefs, values, and attitudes about home among young generation, middle age, and mature generation.
Identify, synthesize, and translate findings into insights and opportunities that can lead to possible concepts.
An ethnographic research project about the meaning of home who are in different life phases
Role
Coordinate ethnographic research from planning to practicing activities with team members and qualified participants
Actively participated in team discussion and fulfilled commitments that contribute to the team's overall success
While home is an important source of life-time influeces, memories, and supports, the generation gap is a problem in most families. Maintaining the communication and the understanding of different perceptions is critical for future home experience design.
What Does Home Mean to You?
We recognized that the form of a "home" has changed overtimes. Living in a big city like Los Angeles, most people around us left their families for school, work, or hopefully a better life.
We wondered, "What is considered a home?"
"Why do people in different life phases treat their homes differently?"
Participants
Qualitative Understanding of each Generation
P1
Young
P2
Young + Middle
P4
Middle Age
P3
Young + Middle
P5
Mature
In order to have an in-depth understanding of each generation, we interviewed five people from different generations. Each interview was approximately an hour long.
The separation of each generation was based on their life experiences, but not necessarily their age.
Expert
Psychologist
Initiate psychological knowledge for the analysis process came from the expert's interpretation of the participants' behaviors and mental process.
After learning from the highlights of the information we collected, I was responsible for interviewing and putting together a special list of questions for the expert.
Primary Research Planning
In order to let our participants open their minds within an hour, we designed the interview and activities ahead of time.
Setting our knowledge goals was our first step, and then we plugged in the suitable methods.
Our participants' rights were clarified and protected with consent forms before the interview starts.
Team:
x1 interviewer
x1 note taker
x1 video taker
x1 photographer
(Click here to see the detail of our job distribution and the responsibility of each job)
Method:
Guided tour and observation
Consideration:
-
A common ice breaker
-
Broad and open-ended
-
Let the participant feel that they are in control while getting comfortable talking to us
-
Slowly narrow down the conversation
-
Understand their activities, feelings, and attachment at home
Knowledge Goals
"How the experience of living in the present home affects his/her life?"
Process:
-
A Understand and observe the environment of our participant's home with their lead
2. Ask the participants to introduce his/her
"favorite" and "least favorite" spot at home
"What is the participant's character at home?
Method:
Dixid card picking
Consideration:
-
Avoid surface-level information while reaching the deeper meaning
-
Maintain a relaxing and fun mood
-
Allowing participants to turn abstract feelings into metaphorical stories ease the communication process
-
Critique themselves in a harmless way
-
A new/ different perspective
Process:
-
Provide a pile of selected Dixit cards (without houses and furniture) to the participants
2. Ask the participants to pick two cards
base on our questions and talk about them
Q1. "How do you see your home?"
Q2. "How do you think your home sees you?"
"Which part of their homes does not satisfy them?"
Method:
Drawing
Consideration:
-
Drop the limitation of participant's confidence and abilities on drawing
-
Keep the research process fun with engaging activities
-
Has no constraints and helps the participant to communicate his/her thoughts
Process:
-
Provide a sheet of 11x17" paper, colored markers, and stickers
2. Ask participants to create an image of
"How his/her ideal home would be?"
3. Ask the participants to talk about the image
that he/she created
Analyze and Visualize the Process
Explain Abstract Relationships with Diagrams
Laying out the data in different diagrams allows us to focus on one aspect at a time and think deeper. These diagrams help us explain various abstract relationships. This process makes more sense of the information we collected during the ethnographic interviews.
The diagrams below show the activities, interactions, people, objects, environment, the transformation of messages that are involved at home, and the system that enable the activities.
A&I + POEMS Framework
(Activity & Interaction) + (People, Object, Environment, Message, Service)
User Experience Framework
(Physical, Cognitive, Social, Culture, Emotion)
Physical, cognitive, social, culture, and emotion are five human factors. We captured the human values of our participants with the data we collected and five analytical diagrams.
The Ethnographer's Questions
(Meaning, Pattern, Sense of Order, Roles)
Answering a set of questions per diagram allows us to think and analyze the believes and behaviors of different generations with empathy.
Social Order
This diagram allows us to think through the hierarchy among different generations. Who is at the top and who is at the bottom? Who is in? Who is out? How do you know? How do you join the "in" crowd? Is there a rite of passage? Are there barriers to entry? What are they?
User Experience Journey Map
(Doing, Thinking, Feeling, Context, Devices)
This diagram allows us to think through the hierarchy among different generations. Who is at the top and who is at the bottom? Who is in? Who is out? How do you know? How do you join the "in" crowd? Is there a rite of passage? Are there barriers to entry? What are they?
Bordieu's Four Forms of Capital
(Economic, social, symbol, cultural)
We examined each type of capital with questions, "How are they presented?" "Who is powerful and who is not? Why?" " Are there different levels in each type? What are they?" "Which types of power are considered legitimate by different generations?
Reflection
Clarify the Questions in Analyzing Process and Dig Deeper
Narrow Down the Topic
I realized that we did not fully answer the questions when we were analyzing the data. If we get them correctly, we can dig deeper and find more interesting insights and opportunities instead of repeating some common findings.
For example:
When we answered the Ethnographer's Questions, the question should be "What does the meaning of home mean to different generations," instead of simply "What is the meaning of home for different generations."
As for the question from Ethnographer's Questions, "What are the role of participants and non-participants?" We should not only think about the "role of different generations," but also "How would different treat different generations treat the different people who belong and do not belong to their home."
When we analyze the social order of different generations, we kept thinking about the contribution of each generation to answer the questions: "Who is in? Who is out? How do you know? How do you join the 'in' crowd? Is there a rite of passage?" However, we should also consider "who or what can be part of the home? Is there any barrier to be part of the home?"
If we narrow down to a group of people with the same race, income level, or family formation, etc, we might be able to find better insights and opportunities that specifically help this group of people. The content would also be more unique.
Make Sure the Analytical diagrams stay close to our topic and goal
It would be better if we can turn our heads around and write on their relationship with "home" at each touchpoint when we were working on the User Experience Journey Map. Therefore, we can have a better understanding of their journey with "home" instead of only listing their journey over weekdays and weekends.